Every year around the Holiday Season, despite protests heard round the Hollywood Hills, I whip up a heaping (as in the cookies fall over the side of the plate) batch of my Nana’s Cookies.
Picture it…Sicily 1890…Maria Rosario Caldora (no not Sophia Petrillo) sailed from her hometown along the Mediterranean straight into Ellis Island. Among the items packed tightly in her cargo aboard the ship were her husband Michael (fun fact – he’s the man I’m named after), some goats (pure speculation) and this traditional, now infamous Anisette Cookie Recipe.
Fast forward a century give or take a decade and an awkward first-semester college freshman (that’s me!) was standing in Anna’s daughter’s (my Grandma Angie) kitchen, learning the craft of Nana’s baking.
The thing about baking (as I learned from Gail Simmons on Just Desserts) is that all your measurements need to be very exact.
The thing about this cookie recipe is that none of the measurements are very exact.
My Grandma scrawled out the ingredients and directions on a piece of paper dated 12/23/01. Here we are nearly nine years later and that piece of paper is still in my possession and still intact!
Now before I share my Nana’s Cookie recipe with you, here are a few glowing reviews I’ve received over the past several years:
- These cookies are dry.
- Why are they in the shape of the letter S?
- Are they supposed to be this dry?
- You are making another batch…it’s only November?
- This cookies are great...for dunking in coffee.
- A Pictorial Comment from our last Christmas Soiree:
8. You used how many cups of flour?
9. Need...Milk…..STAT!!!
10. The fact that you are still eating those cookies is really stressing me out.
Until then, Happy Holidays…and stock up on 2% milk. Trust me, the cookies are better when you dunk ‘em.
10. The fact that you are still eating those cookies is really stressing me out.
Ya know what, all of you Grinches can keep your Gingerbread, Chocolate Chips and fancy Cookie Cutter shaped, frosted delights for yourselves. They may be a little rough around the edges (literally), but I stand by Nana’s Cookies…no matter how many teeth I’ve chipped over the years.
I know, I know…I’ve really whet your appetite now haven’t I. Well the wait is over, below is the recipe for Nana’s Christmas Cookies. Bake at you own risk:
INGREDIENTS
10 Eggs (Beaten)
1 cup of Crisco (heat it up in the microwave so its liquid)
5 Teaspoons Baking Powder
2 cups Sugar
1/2 cup Anisette
2 Teaspoons Vanilla
6+ cups of Flour
DIRECTIONS
Mix all the ingredients and then slowly add the flour in one cup at a time. As the mixture starts to form it will get sticky, start kneading it with your hands in a big bowl. Keep adding flour (may be more than 6 cups) until the mixture isn’t too sticky. Let it sit for 30 minutes in the fridge.
Form S-shapes (still unsure why) with the dough and then cook in the oven for approximately 20 minutes (or until the smoke detector goes off) at 350 degrees.
Make sure you use parchment paper or grease the cookie sheets.
You can add some sprinkles before they go in for fun.
I’m already looking forward to all the fun new criticisms I can add to my ever-growing list. We’re taking off for the Christmas break, but 99pLAtes will be back in January with all new posts of LA foodie favorites.
Until then, Happy Holidays…and stock up on 2% milk. Trust me, the cookies are better when you dunk ‘em.